Debating evidence, method & Inferences: Oak vs Koch – Part 3

Continued from part 2 Links to previous parts are here: https://nileshoak.wordpress.com/2017/05/06/debating-evidence-method-inferences-oak-vs-koch-part-1/ https://nileshoak.wordpress.com/2017/05/15/debating-evidence-method-inferences-oak-vs-koch-part-2/ — And thus, Dieter Koch began with wrong argumentation, followed by not comprehending my scientific argument (that how big a separation does not matter. Period), followed by superfluous and unnecessary speculation, he comes a full circle, when he repeats his arguments (which was…

Presence (Ramayana) & absence (Mahabharata) of Pole Star – Implication for Chronology

Shrimati Rupa Bhaty provides summary of the issue, succinctly, in her short note, below महाभारत काल के विषय मे चिन्ता की तब ये सामने बात आयी कि अरुन्धती आगे क्यों आ गयीं और ध्रुव तारा सिर्फ़ ध्यान मे ही क्योंकर रहा। अगर अरुन्धती ही आगे हो कर सप्तऋषिओं को खीच रही थीं मगर किसके इर्द…

Debating evidence, method & Inferences: Oak vs Koch – Part 2

Continued from part 1 here: https://nileshoak.wordpress.com/2017/05/06/debating-evidence-method-inferences-oak-vs-koch-part-1/ — Now, Dieter Koch claims to turn next objection of his, Instead, let us turn to another objection that has been made against his approach. Vyasa is talking about astronomical observations (omens) that were made in the very year of the war, more precisely only a few days before…

Nilesh Oak’s prediction & assertion

My prediction & assertion…. — The events and astronomy descriptions of Ramayana and Mahabharata will be employed as golden standards to validate and predict, testify and claim accuracy of modern astronomy software, for timeline that goes back in antiquity to about 15000+ years.

Debating evidence, method & Inferences: Oak vs Koch – Part 1

Shri Dieter Koch wrote an article titled ‘Arundhati, Vasishtha, and Nilesh Oak’s Dating of the Mahabharata War. A Critical Examination by Dieter Koch’ sometime in late March/early April 2017. I was copied on it. I responded to his article and we exchanged couple of times before he decides to quit the discussion. The discussion is…