Praise for my book – When did the Mahabharata War happen? The Mystery of Arundhati

“You have done a great job. I requested astronomers to consider if Arundhati had gone ahead of Vasisth in 1971, when I published ‘Swayambhu’ . But nobody cared. You are the first to do the great job!”

– P V Vartak (Author of ‘Swayambhu’ & ‘Wastav Ramayana’)

“Grueling and unfaltering logic”

I have to thank you for being the cause for a quantum leap in my own knowledge of general astronomy as well as Hindu astronomy / calendrical systems over a very short span of time. In some ways the effect of your book has some parallels with Rajiv Malhotra’s ‘Being Different’, though in a very different context. RM never intended his book as a primer on Dharma / Hinduism – but nevertheless it introduced many aspects of Dharma in a light which would be new even to a practitioner. Similarly, even though I am sure you never intended your book to act as an exploration of key astronomical principles and Vedic astronomy – that has definitely been a key side benefit, at least from my perspective.

“Indology” has been populated by linguists and my respect for their work has gone down by several notches when I look at the shoddy assumptions many are prone to make. Science and rigor the way Nilesh Oak has used seems to be unknown to these Indologists. I bet that not one of those horse bone chewers can understand what Archeo-astronomy means. Their awareness extends to looking at Archeo-asses and saying it was not Equus caballus.

I am simply ‘natmastak’ to Shri Oak for the amazing piece of deductive reasoning applied by him in interpreting the ‘Arundhati is leading Vasistha’ remark. I think Shri Oak is not only on sound footing but also has clearly exhibited every ‘lakshan’ of a true seeker of knowledge in the finest Indian traditions. I cannot recall if he mentioned whether anybody else (other than him) thought of the EOA approach. If he is the first one, he deserves billions of thanks from all the Bharatiyas in the last 7000+ years. Oak saheb, aamcha maanacha mujra sweekar karava hee vinanti.

It is interesting how all Indologists the world over talk about linguistics and horse, but never mentions archaeoastronomy! Perhaps the focus of the national and international debate on Aryan Invasion/Migration Theory needs to change.

I do not want to sound obsequious, but the work you have done is nothing less than tremendous. Thank you, and keep it up.

I have verified Nilesh Oak’s elimination of “errors”. A bow! Excellent!

Your rigorous methodology was simply a pleasure to read and that got me started off on my efforts to dabble in archeoastronomy.


2 thoughts on “Praise for my book – When did the Mahabharata War happen? The Mystery of Arundhati

  1. I wonder whether Dr. Vartak has seen my observations and comments on your (and his) claims regarding year and date of the war, darkness on 14th night and Balarama Tirthyatra. Does he endorse your statement that Bhishma spent 100 days on deathbed?

    • Don’t know if he has seen your comments.

      When he responded , a while ago, to my book, he raised few issues about some aspects but did not say anything specific about my assertion of Bhishma on bed of arrows for more than 92 days. However, since he does stick to 16 October 5561 BCE, as first day of Mahabharata war, he better not object, even on emotional ground, for objective reality separates day of winter solstice from 16 October, by 108 days.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s